2018 Election Results
Proposition 11: Emergency Crews Lose Out
Framing Prop. 11 as necessary to protect public safety was a strong argument, but it didn’t help that the opposition failed to file paperwork in time to have their arguments against the measure included in the state’s voter guide.

Proposition 11, which rewrites California’s Labor Code to allow private ambulance companies to require paramedics and EMTs to be on call during breaks, cruised to an easy victory on election night, with 60 percent voter support. The result wasn’t surprising; polling showed the measure was leading by a two-to-one margin. Prop. 11’s primary supporter, private ambulance company American Medical Response, vastly outspent the opposition, pouring $22 million into the campaign to argue that response times to emergencies would increase if the measure were defeated.
Read More Election Coverage
The proposition came in the wake of a 2016 California Supreme Court ruling that private security guards are required to be given uninterrupted rest breaks. That ruling likely would apply to the state’s private sector EMTs and paramedics, who are also on call during breaks, and who have filed several lawsuits challenging the practice, including one against AMR. Last year, a legislative attempt to solve the problem stalled in the face of AMR opposition; one of the sticking points was whether the bill would protect AMR from active lawsuits. (As written, Prop. 11 shields AMR from liability regarding breaks in pending litigation.)
Framing Prop. 11 as necessary to protect public safety was a strong argument, but it didn’t help that the opposition, led by the United EMS Workers, an American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees local, failed to file paperwork in time to have its arguments against the measure included in the state’s voter guide. (Disclosure: AFSCME is a financial supporter of this website.) AMR largely drowned out the local’s attempts to highlight the grueling working conditions faced by emergency workers, and the need for extra staffing to allow more predictable breaks.
What remains to be seen is whether Prop. 11 will in fact shield AMR and other private ambulance companies from pending lawsuits, a decision likely to be determined in court. Jason Brollini, president-executive director of United EMS Workers, estimates that AMR could owe workers as much as $100 million in settlements if the cases are allowed to proceed.
Copyright Capital & Main

-
Column - California UncoveredMay 5, 2025
How Did Farmers Respond When the Trump Administration Suddenly Stopped Paying Them to Help Feed Needy Californians?
-
Latest NewsMay 5, 2025
Kaiser and Mental Health Care Workers Reach Tentative Agreement
-
Featured VideoMay 2, 2025
Inside the Plan to Use Trans Student-Athletes to Push Voters to the Right
-
Column - State of InequalityMay 15, 2025
Innovative Medi-Cal Expansion Threatened by Budget and Trump Pressures
-
The SlickMay 12, 2025
Push to Make Big Oil Pay for Climate Damage Losing Steam in California Legislature
-
The SlickMay 8, 2025
Solar Grants Held Hostage in Pennsylvania Legislature — as Demand Soars
-
Featured VideoMay 15, 2025
A League of Her Own: Transgender Athlete AB Hernandez Faces Down Hecklers
-
Latest NewsMay 9, 2025
‘We Are in a Moment of Unparalleled Peril’: An Interview With Naomi Klein