728 x 90
728 x 90

Key Democrats Could Deny Farm Workers Overtime Pay as Battle Goes Down to the Wire

Photo by David BaconPhoto by David Bacon

As Assembly Bill 1066, which would grant overtime pay to California farm workers, heads for a vote in the Assembly, farm workers and faith and civil rights groups are fighting for the votes needed to pass it. In June similar legislation, Assembly Bill 2757, failed when 14 Democrats either voted no, or failed to vote at all — the functional equivalent of a no vote.

On Tuesday, activists and workers mounted human billboards around the offices of two Assemblymembers — Tom Daly in Anaheim and Evan Low in Cupertino. On Wednesday the billboarders’ target was Adrin Nazarian in Van Nuys. In the June vote Low voted no, while Daly and Nazarian were no-shows.

AB 1066 phases in overtime pay, so that farm workers will receive time-and-a-half after 9.5 hours in a day in 2019, nine hours in 2020, 8.5 hours in 2021, and eight hours in 2022 (when they will also receive double time after 12 hours).

Pressure began to mount last week, when legislators, faith leaders and workers participated in a 24-hour fast to call attention to the overtime issue. Commitments to fast came from 11 Assemblymembers, including Lorena Gonzalez (who introduced the bill), Rob Bonta, Joaquin Arambula, Nora Campos, David Chiu, Kansen Chu, Cristina Garcia, Kevin McCarty, Jose Medina, Miguel Santiago and Tony Thurmond. Earlier this week, the State Senate passed the overtime bill and sent it to the Assembly.

California growers had a gross income of $54 billion in 2014, giving them significant political clout and complicating the task of corralling the Democratic votes needed to pass the overtime legislation. Farm workers, on the other hand, have a median income just above $14,000, and 80 percent are immigrants.

Nazarian’s vote has been particularly controversial. He represents the 44th Assembly District, whose residents are 44 percent Latino. In his reelection fight, he faces an ESL teacher and immigration attorney, Angela Rupert, who has attacked him for not supporting farm worker overtime in June.

Daly also represents a district, Anaheim, with a growing Latino population that has helped elect Latino Democratic Congress members, replacing a number of Republicans. Low represents Cupertino, home of Silicon Valley tech giant Apple. Given his heavily urban district, his vote favoring growers puzzled many observers.

In recent weeks both Jewish and African-American groups have sought to win over reluctant Democrats. Referring to the New Deal-era labor law that exempted agricultural workers from federal protections, Rabbi Aryeh Cohen called their exclusion from overtime provisions that cover other workers “a last vestige of this racist holdover” in an article in the Jewish Journal. Alice A. Huffman, president of the California State Conference of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP), wrote a letter to legislators declaring, “for the last 78 years California has failed to bring equality in our workforce. This can no longer be justified or tolerated.”

This week the Assembly passed a similar overtime bill for domestic workers, making the Domestic Workers Bill of Rights a permanent law. It replaces a previous measure that expired after three years. The bill is now on Governor Jerry Brown’s desk. Whether the farm worker bill also goes before Brown will likely come down to the votes of a handful of Assembly Democrats.

Print Friendly
  • Dario

    This bill will be devastating for California farm workers. Yes, it will cost farmers more, but the farm workers will make less. Farmers will hire more workers, not pay overtime to their current workers. Ultimately it will hurt agriculture all over the state of California. How does this make sense to anyone?

  • geoff schneider

    Overtime will result in fewer hours – something laborers don’t want. And it will result in more cash payments – which laborers do like but politicians don’t.

  • Karl Phelps

    I love that this bill is being touted by the left wing agenda as righting a great injustice to the modern farmworker. The reality is that agriculture is as seasonally based as the ski industry or other similar season based economies. This bill will only hurt the very farmworker it espouses to help. Growers will simply cut back workers hours to comply with the new rules and avoid overtime OR they will start trading workers with other operations so that everyone can keep their productivity, profit, and pay the same. We will all now have double the workforce who works 1/3 less per operation as exists today. I have over 85 full time agriculture workers who have been asking me daily why the state government is trying to take working hours and pay away from them.

    • Chuck

      Dems doing their best to break the back of any and all industry. Prepare for a foreign dependant food supply because that is where we are heading.

  • Susan Knieriemen

    Way past time for CA to pass this bill. Shame on us for taking so long to recognize the valuable contribution the farm workers make to our society.

  • Albert Ulrich

    Let’s go California (& Florida, etc.) can on the train before it leaves the station.
    Don’t tell me that Democrats are BOUGHT off TOO!

    • Doug

      Most agricultural workers understand that this law will hurt them in the long run. Their hours will be cut back and another employee will take the extra work. Once again the unintended consequences hurt the people the very folks they are trying to help.

  • Carol

    IMHO, these are not true Democrats, but DINOs

  • Pingback: Farmworker Overtime Pay Bill on Bubble - LA Progressive()

Print Friendly